|
“It
is an important and popular fact that things are not always what they seem.
For instance, on the planet Earth, man had always assumed that he was more
intelligent than dolphins because he had achieved so much - the wheel, New
York, wars and so on - while all the dolphins had ever done was muck about
in the water having a good time. But conversely, the dolphins had always
believed that they were far more intelligent than man - for precisely the
same reason.” - Douglas Adams, the Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy.
|
In the 1960s,
Dolphin researchers began the difficult process of figuring out what all the
squeaks, clicks and whistles that the dolphins make mean. Over the past four
decades, it has become clear that the vocalizations of the magnificent animals
contain structure, syntax and rules, presumably rules of grammar.
The most
important finding (so far) has come about in only the past month, and it is
this: Dolphins have names.
"We thought this was
something fairly unique to human language," said Vincent M. Janik of the University of St. Andrews
in Scotland,
the lead author of a paper on the subject in The Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences. "Now we find it in dolphins, too."
Let’s be clear on
this. We are not talking about some kind of ‘I am here’ vocalization. This is a
name in the sense that, in addition to using it in the first person, it is also
used in the second and third person, in other words, Dolphins will use names to refer to other Dolphins.
If Dolphins have
names, and a structured language (as reported by Markov and Ostrovskaya of the Russian Academy of Sciences) then where does
that lead?
Knowing the
difference between I, you, him, her and them is a pretty good indicator for
sentience. Unfortunately, humans and dolphins share little in common. We cannot
survive for long away from our own environments. We have very few common frames
of reference. We do not have a shared history to any meaningful degree from
which we can find common ground to help us understand them.
Dolphins understand
us pretty well, at least those that interact with us in captivity. They are
quick to learn, and become bored easily. Dolphins can collaborate on creating
new ‘tricks’ that we have never seen before when asked to. They are careful,
when dealing with ‘new’ people to not freak the person out, seemingly aware of
how fearful people can be of touching a ‘wild’ animal.
Dolphin
intelligence has never been in question. Dolphin sentience however, the idea
that they can consider (if they so chose to) the concept of ‘I think, therefore
I am’, is a new one, but this is an idea that is becoming harder and harder to
dismiss.
Dolphins
understand us, and are (apparently) quite tolerant of us. They have even been
known to help divers in distress. We do not understand them to any meaningful
degree, beyond knowing that they can be of use to us. The US Navy uses Dolphins
for mine sweeping.
From the US Navy
Marine Mammal Program website:
“In
the operation of these systems, a dolphin waits to receive a cue from its
handler before it begins to search a specific area using its biological sonar
called echolocation. When a dolphin echolocates, it emits a series of clicks
that bounce off an object and return to the dolphin, allowing a dolphin to
construct a mental image of the object. The dolphin reports back to its
handler, giving one response if a target object is detected and a different
response if no target object is detected. If a mine-like target is detected,
the handler sends the dolphin to mark the location of the object so it can be
avoided by Navy vessels or dealt with by Navy divers.”
So we are using
sentient beings to do dangerous work for us without affording them the same
rights and privileges as we expect for ourselves.
There is a word
for that. There’s probably a word for it
in Delphinic as well, and it probably don’t sound too nice.
Dolphins are
killed, captured, poisoned, eaten and used as slave labor. By us.
It is true that,
apart from the eating (for the most part) we still do the same things to each
other. The difference? We know that is wrong, and we know because when we do
it, the people we are doing it to tend to say ‘No! Please don’t do that!’ or
words to that effect.
I don’t know what
the answer is to this problem. I want
us to understand Dolphins, and for that we need to study them. Consider, what
would Dolphins say to us if we finally learn their languages?
I cannot become
to imagine what it would be like to truly have a conversation with an
intelligent, non-human life form. Would they be able to fill in some gaps for
us in history? What legends would they share (if any)? Do they have a concept
of God and religion? Do they know where Atlantis is?
Don’t get me
wrong, I’m not assigning Dolphins some kind of moral high ground. I don’t think
we can do that, since our and their concepts of morality would be completely
different and probably incompatible to a large extent.
The truth is
though, I don’t know enough about them. And neither do you. One of the things
we did invent (apart from New York
and Wars) was the internet, and I think it’s pretty cool. Because now, when you
don’t know something, you can go find out about it, and that is what I would
like you to do now.
Go learn about
Dolphins. Here are some links to help you:
http://www.apa.org/monitor/oct04/smarter.html
- Smarter than the average chimp.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dolphins
- Wiki entry for Dolphins
http://www.bluevoice.org/ -
BlueVoice.org – Saving Dolphins and
Whales
http://www.dolphins.org/ - Dolphin Research Center
http://www.dolphin-institute.org/
- The Dolphin Institute
Knowledge is
Power. Please, learn as much as you can about dolphins and share what you know
with your friends and family. This is a simple thing to do that can be very
powerful – raise the level of consciousness about dolphins and we you raise the
level of debate, which in turns leads to positive changes!
Vaughan
Wynne-Jones, author of Being Human, a Guide to Metaphysics, is currently taking
time out of writing his next book to annoy as many people as possible about
dolphins until they take the hint and stop abusing these wonderful, intelligent
and sentient beings.
Copyright © 2006,
Vaughan Wynne-Jones, all rights reserved. Article may be republished as long as
a link is included back to this original.
|